Lawsuits
Swipe sideways to see the whole diagram, or open it full size.
Federal Suspension Case
In November 2025, I sued University of Kentucky officials in federal court to stop their investigation of my speech and to end my suspension from teaching and my ban from the law building (the latter has since been lifted), which the University imposed after I posted my petition for international military action to end Israel to AALS discussion lists. Woodcock v. Capilouto, No. 5:25-cv-00424 (E.D. Ky.).
Filings in this case are collected here.
Sixth Circuit Appeal in Federal Suspension Case
The District Court in the Federal Suspension Case initially abstained. I appealed, and the Sixth Circuit reversed in August 2026 and sent the case back for a ruling on my motion to end the investigation and return to teaching. Woodcock v. Capilouto, No. 26-5057 (6th Cir.).
Filings in this appeal are collected here.
State Suspension Case
Because federal courts cannot hear state-law claims against state officials, I brought my contract, Kentucky Campus Free Speech Protection Act, Kentucky Civil Rights Act, and Kentucky constitutional claims against the investigation and suspension in state court. The case was filed in Fayette Circuit Court in July 2026, transferred to Franklin Circuit Court (Nos. 26-CI-01010 and 26-CI-01017), and consolidated with the state dean case (of which see below).
Filings in this case are collected here.
Federal Dean Case (Voluntarily Dismissed)
In July 2026, I sued to block the University’s appointment of Gregory Van Tatenhove as dean of the law school over the faculty’s objection that he is unqualified. The appointment violates my First Amendment right of expressive association because I joined the faculty in part to send the message that my scholarship is subject to the review of peer scholars. I voluntarily dismissed the case in August 2026 and refiled it in state court. Woodcock v. Van Tatenhove, No. 5:26-cv-00262 (E.D. Ky.).
Filings in this case are collected here.
State Dean Case
My challenge to the dean appointment under the Kentucky Constitution and the University’s contractual commitment to accreditation standards. Franklin Circuit Court No. 26-CI-00885.
Filings in this case are collected here.
The major filings in all cases are provided below.
-
Response to the Suggestion of Mootness
I responded to the University officials’ suggestion that the November 19 hearing on my motion for a preliminary injunction is no longer needed. My reassignment away from teaching continues through the academic year, and the President’s findings have not issued, so the controversy remains live.
-
University Officials’ Notice of Completion of the Investigation in the State Cases
The University officials notified the Franklin Circuit Court that the investigator has completed the investigation.
-
Response to the Notice of Completion of the Investigation
I responded to the University officials’ notice that the investigation is complete. My response points out that the investigation does not end at least until the President issues his findings, which have not issued, and that I remain reassigned away from teaching.
-
University Officials’ Notice of Issuance of the Investigative Report
The University officials gave notice of issuance of the investigative report.
-
University Officials’ Response to the Motion to Amend
The University officials said that they do not oppose the filing of my second amended complaint but oppose my other requests.
-
University Officials’ Opposition to Expedited Discovery
The University officials opposed my motion for limited expedited discovery.
-
University Officials’ Suggestion of Mootness
The University officials filed a notice suggesting that, following issuance of the investigative report, my motion for a preliminary injunction is moot and the November 19 hearing is no longer needed.
-
Motion to Amend the Complaint in the State Suspension Case
In the state suspension case, I moved for leave to file a verified amended and supplemental complaint. The new complaint restates my claims in a single pleading, adds events since September, including my removal from teaching for a third consecutive semester and the more than $848,000 the University has been billed for the investigator’s law…
-
Attorney General’s Reply in Support of His Motion to Dismiss
The Attorney General filed a reply in support of his motion to dismiss.
-
Order on the Motion to Amend and the Motion for Discovery
The Court ordered the University officials to respond to my motions to amend and for discovery by November 10, extended my deadline to respond to Secretary McMahon’s motion to November 20, and denied my request for an order under the All Writs Act. Earlier, on October 7, the Court dismissed the University of Kentucky as…
