Lawsuits
Swipe sideways to see the whole diagram, or open it full size.
Federal Suspension Case
In November 2025, I sued University of Kentucky officials in federal court to stop their investigation of my speech and to end my suspension from teaching and my ban from the law building (the latter has since been lifted), which the University imposed after I posted my petition for international military action to end Israel to AALS discussion lists. Woodcock v. Capilouto, No. 5:25-cv-00424 (E.D. Ky.).
Filings in this case are collected here.
Sixth Circuit Appeal in Federal Suspension Case
The District Court in the Federal Suspension Case initially abstained. I appealed, and the Sixth Circuit reversed in August 2026 and sent the case back for a ruling on my motion to end the investigation and return to teaching. Woodcock v. Capilouto, No. 26-5057 (6th Cir.).
Filings in this appeal are collected here.
State Suspension Case
Because federal courts cannot hear state-law claims against state officials, I brought my contract, Kentucky Campus Free Speech Protection Act, Kentucky Civil Rights Act, and Kentucky constitutional claims against the investigation and suspension in state court. The case was filed in Fayette Circuit Court in July 2026, transferred to Franklin Circuit Court (Nos. 26-CI-01010 and 26-CI-01017), and consolidated with the state dean case (of which see below).
Filings in this case are collected here.
Federal Dean Case (Voluntarily Dismissed)
In July 2026, I sued to block the University’s appointment of Gregory Van Tatenhove as dean of the law school over the faculty’s objection that he is unqualified. The appointment violates my First Amendment right of expressive association because I joined the faculty in part to send the message that my scholarship is subject to the review of peer scholars. I voluntarily dismissed the case in August 2026 and refiled it in state court. Woodcock v. Van Tatenhove, No. 5:26-cv-00262 (E.D. Ky.).
Filings in this case are collected here.
State Dean Case
My challenge to the dean appointment under the Kentucky Constitution and the University’s contractual commitment to accreditation standards. Franklin Circuit Court No. 26-CI-00885.
Filings in this case are collected here.
The major filings in all cases are provided below.
-
Motion for Limited Expedited Discovery
I asked the Court for leave to serve fifteen targeted document requests and five interrogatories in preparation for the November 19 preliminary-injunction hearing.
-
Motion for Leave to File a Second Amended and Supplemental Complaint
I moved for leave to file a second amended and supplemental verified complaint. The new complaint adds the events of the fifteen months since the University suspended me, banned me from the law building, and began investigating my speech.
-
Order Denying Temporary Restraining Order
On November 3, the Court denied my motion for a temporary restraining order and set a preliminary-injunction hearing for November 19 in Louisville, calling the issues ‘important questions worthy of further evidentiary presentation.’ The Court issued a corrected version of the opinion on November 5.
-
University Officials’ Reply in Support of Judgment on the Pleadings
The University officials filed a reply in support of their motion for judgment on the pleadings.
-
Secretary McMahon’s Motion to Dismiss
Secretary of Education Linda McMahon moved to dismiss the claims against her.
-
Notice That the Second Evidence Review Has Closed
I notified the Court that the Second Evidence Review has closed, and that the University has told the Court that the investigator anticipates submitting a final report by November 2. I renewed my request that the Court rule on my motion for a temporary restraining order or, if the Court needs more time, direct the…
-
Response to the Attorney General’s Motion to Dismiss
I responded to the Attorney General’s motion to dismiss my two claims against SJR 55, the Establishment Clause claim and the free speech claim. SJR 55 commands every public university in Kentucky to adopt policies to “combat antisemitism” that use as their guide a definition whose examples “classify core political speech about Israel and Zionism…
-
Supplemental Response to the Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings
On October 16, I filed a supplemental response to the University officials’ motion for judgment on the pleadings. My response argues that immunity does not bar my claims. It also argues that my suspension, my exclusion from the law school building, faculty meetings and student advising, and the investigation into my speech were retaliation against…
-
Notice of Supplemental Authority on the Word ‘Should’ in ABA Interpretation 203-1
At the September 30 hearing, the defendants argued for the first time that ABA Interpretation 203-1 does not bind the University because it says a dean “should not” be appointed over the stated objection of a substantial majority of the faculty, rather than “shall not.” I responded that Interpretation 203-1 states what the mandatory requirement…
-
Order Denying a Temporary Injunction
The court denied my motion for a temporary injunction setting aside Dean Van Tatenhove’s appointment. The court found that “the faculty participated in good faith in each of the searches, that the University failed to hire, or even extend offers, to numerous well-qualified candidates approved by the faculty, and then hired the only candidate who…
